Monday, October 27, 2008

Says it All...

As a Pro-Lifer (even registered as one), I often get a lot of slack, both directly and indirectly, for being "blind" to other issues, not truly understanding the tough situation young, unwed mothers are in, or for trying to take away a woman's reproductive rights. I recently received this letter from Priests for Life, written to the Pro-Abortion Candidates. I think it says it all.

An Open Letter to “Pro-choice” Candidates

October 27, 2008

Dear brothers and sisters,

In these days you are seeking the votes of your fellow Americans for public office. At the same time, you take the position that abortion, however regrettable it may be, should remain legal.

I write to express the convictions of tens of millions of citizens. Your position is a blatant contradiction to the very meaning of public service, the first requirement of which is to be able to tell the difference between serving the public and killing the public!

We ask, first of all, Have you ever seen an abortion? So many who defend abortion’s legality cannot even bring themselves to look at the horrifying pictures of children torn apart by the procedure ( But if we cannot look at it, why should we tolerate it?

We likewise ask, Are you willing to publicly describe what you think should be legal? Abortionist Dr. Martin Haskell, in sworn testimony, described the “D and E” abortion procedure, still legal throughout our nation, by saying, “Typically the skull is brought out in fragments rather than as a unified piece…" (Madison, WI, May 27, 1999, Case No. 98-C-0305-S). In the same case, abortionist Dr. Hylan Raymond Giles, when asked, “Can the heart of a fetus or embryo still be beating during a suction curettage abortion as the fetus or embryo comes down the cannula?” answered, “For a few seconds to a minute, yes.”

When you say the word “abortion,” is this what you mean? When you say it should be legal, are you willing to quote those who explain what it is?

Your position is undermining the fabric of our nation. We repeat to you again the question posed by Mother Teresa in her speech at the National Prayer Breakfast in Washington DC on February 3, 1994. “And if we accept that a mother can kill even her own child, how can we tell other people not to kill one another?”

We have not yet heard a “pro-choice” candidate answer any of these questions.
That’s why people cannot vote for you, and you shouldn’t be asking for their vote. If you can’t respect and protect the life of a little baby, how are you supposed to respect and protect our lives, or any other right we possess?

When you ask someone for your vote, you are actually asking them to share in your failure to protect these children. You’re asking them to share in the deception by which you justify that failure. You’re asking them, too, to contradict the meaning of public service. They are not morally permitted to say yes to what you are asking.
We in the pro-life movement do not need any reminders about the plight of young mothers. We serve them every day, providing real alternatives to abortion.

Nor do we accept the accusation that we are narrowly focused on a “single issue.” We are not ashamed of the fact that we recognize a holocaust when we see one, and that we understand the foundation, heart, and core of our concern for all the other issues – life itself.

We’re not a vote for you to court or an interest group for you to appease. Rather, our movement represents the heart and core of every movement for justice. That is why, whether you end up elected to public office or not, we will be there – in the halls of government, in the media, and on the streets of every city, town, and countryside across America – pressing the cause of justice for a group of human beings whose rights you have forgotten.

We will neither cease to remind you, nor will we wait for you to remember. Our cause is as great as America itself, and it will prevail. May you have the wisdom to join us.


Fr. Frank Pavone
National Director, Priests for Life
Priests for Life
PO Box 141172
Staten Island, NY 10314
phone: 718-980-4400
fax: 718-980-6515
email: [email protected]


Karey said...

Ya, but the pro-choice candidate is going to give tax cuts to the middle class! And isn't money more important that life?! Obviously I'm kidding. As I was reading this wonderful letter, an Obama ad was on t.v. all about how I'm going to get more tax cuts if he is elected, and the contrast to what I was reading was kind of interesting.

This letter was so well put. I feel that the disgusting truth about what abortion is shouldn't be hidden just because it's too shocking to face and makes us uncomfortable. That's the very reason why we should be talking about it! There are so many pro-choicers who are normal, loving people, and I just have to believe they have never had to really think about what it is they support. It's brutal, horrible, and they wouldn't want to watch it being done to a puppy, much less a little innocent baby. It's like if, as a society, we put it in this little box and call it "reproductive rights", then it becomes all nice and neat and the horror of it is hidden and we don't have to think about it. Anyways, thanks for sharing this.

LifeHopes said...

Father Frank does have a gift!

I applaud him for addressing the pro-choice candidates directly, and for never giving up hope on even them.

We have to pray, pray, pray for this nation right now.

AND work, work, work, to help get out the pro-life vote.

Pray like everything depends upon God and work like everything depends on us.

Meridith said...


I don't know if you saw my post on "Why I am Pro-Life"... but here is a link...